Nasty here today…sticky, warm, windy…tornado weather. Which is not quite as bad as earthquake weather, mind you.
Horrid week here at the homestead, hence the lack of posting. I work a full day, then pick the kids up from school, and start my second job as math teacher. This week is areas, volumes and conversions, relatively simple stuff. The Boychild will not even read the instructions, clearly printed on the paper in front of him. He just plunges ahead into the problems, assumes he knows how to solve them, and invariably has to go re-do them all, leading to massive frustration. He gets angry that he has to re-do the paper, I get angry because he didn’t bother to read the instructions, nor apparently paid any attention when the material was covered in class. Yelling ensues.
It does no good to speak to him of potentially failing math, causing the automatic placement in remedial math going into the 6th grade. Not even the addendum that said class is going to be full of fucktards and bullies makes a dent. It does no good to speak to him of the future, and any hopes/plans he has for it. He’s ten, almost eleven…his “future” is what’s on TV that night, or going out to the back yard to play. I do not hold to the latter too much, no ten year old knows what they want to do when they grow up, nor are they capable of processing “fry cook” as something to be avoided. They have no frame of reference, other than what we tell them, and we clearly have an agenda in his mind. What he can’t grasp is our agenda is solely that he succeeds at his current “job” which is the successful passing of the fifth fucking grade.
I have no idea what to do at this point. He does not care one whit about his performance. Doesn’t care if his homework is correct, if he’s learning the material and can do well on the test. Just wants to be done with it as quickly as possible so he can go off and amuse himself. You would think being forced to turn right around and re-do the work would flip some switch in his brain…”Hey, I’m taking TWICE as long to do my homework because I’m not doing it right…maybe I should read the instructions!” That lightbulb has no juice.
We have talked to him until we are anoxic. We have used logic, threats, bribes…I’ve even stooped to tears. (Yes, I fucking WILL emotionally manipulate my children…if you’ve never considered it then you’re not a parent.) Nothing makes an impact. I assume we’ve utterly fucked up by ever telling him he was smart, by allowing him to be placed in the Alpha program (for the SMRT kids, uses outside-the-box teaching methods, lots of logic problems). He thinks he’s smarter than anyone at that school, ergo is absolved of the requirement of learning from them. He seems to have missed the distinction between “smart” and “knowledgeable.”
So I’m honestly at a loss. I hear ads for these frickin’ places in strip malls, “we’ll teach your kid how to learn!” and they just give me the heebie jeebies. Plus, that’s an expenditure we just don’t have room for in the budget right now. Why, WHY won’t he just do the work? I myself have no frame of reference for this reluctance, I can recall nothing but doggedness when faced with school- and homework. But girls are like that I’m told, and we surely see it in the Girlchild. She’s as cheerful doing her math homework as she is playing with her animal toys. Makes it that much harder to deal with the Boychild’s recalcitrance. And no, before someone says it, I don’t think it is a competition thing between them. She, while VERY competitive, is not in this area because she’s three grades behind him. She knows she’ll never catch up, knowledge-wise, until college.
It would almost be easier if there was something actually wrong with him, if he were ADD or autistic. At least then we’d know WHY he was having the trouble, could work at it from that angle. As it is, he just seems to be a daydreamer, mentally wanders off in class, and has trouble concentrating on what he’s doing, because he finds it boring. I am (understandably, I think) very much opposed to the thought of dragging him to a head doctor and asking them to figure out what’s wrong. Nothing is wrong, he’s ten. But he has a FULL measure of both parents’ native stubbornness, and if you’ve met either of us, your eyes probably just started watering.
I suppose family members would call this “chickens coming home to roost.” To which I reply, “bite me.”













on Mar 7th, 2008 at 11:37 am
Guess who was EXACTLY like that at 10 years old.
It took the Marine Corps to shake that mindset out of me.
on Mar 7th, 2008 at 4:38 pm
Is he going off and doing the problems by himself, then coming to you, whereupon you discover he did it wrong? Is he getting the wrong answers or just using the wrong process? What if you had him read the directions to you before each problem?
I assume you’ve explicitly pointed out to him that it winds up taking him longer because he’s trying to work fast.
You’re right; he just wants to be done with it, which wouldn’t be a problem if he was doing it right. I never wasn’t worried about my future, so I can’t speak to that.
All I can think of is to let him fail, get placed in Bonehead Math, and see how much worse it is than Regular Math, with the clear understanding that he’s the reason he wound up there, and it’s up to him to dig out.
The bigger problem is that people tend to approach everything in their lives in basically the same way. If he’s skimping on the drudgery here, figuring he can master the big tests and do well enough, that might wind up being his general approach to life. Which is great as long as the big tests are all that matter. But most of most people’s lives is the drudgery. Unless he’s going to a rock star or actor, this does not bode well.
on Mar 8th, 2008 at 11:44 am
I can imagine your frustration: it is very difficult to watch intelligent people do something totally… not constructive. I have a hard time seeing it in adults, so it must be multiplied by a zillion when it’s your kid.
But, he is only 10. He surely has a lot of time to screw up and then to fix his screw ups. Messing up math in 5th grade does not necessarily equal fry-cook, right? It’s a little early to be pronouncing his doom, isn’t it?
Then again, what do I know, really? I escaped the chickens by not having children, so I can only sympathize mightily – since I know full well the stubbornness of which you speak. ; )
on Mar 10th, 2008 at 10:17 am
David:
>>Is he going off and doing the problems by himself, then coming to you, whereupon you discover he did it wrong?
Yup.
>>Is he getting the wrong answers or just using the wrong process?
Yup. Often claims to have read the instructions, which are always quite adequate, but bones the work. I have taken to checking his work on the scratch paper and pointing out where he went wrong.
>>What if you had him read the directions to you before each problem?
We’re going to try this, yes. He and I had a looong talk, which may or may not have actually sunk in. He’s a fan of logic, so I took him through some logical progression exercises regarding his current behavior vs. the results thereof. They have *spit* FCAT testing this week, so, we’ll see how things go.
Caitlin: The way these fucktards down here put it, his life is OVER if he tanks this test. The 5th grade FCAT tests consist of Math, Science and Reading…none of them are pass/fail, but if he tanks the Math test he automatically goes into remedial math in the 6th grade. It may be it takes that to wake his ass up, but xst.